Copyright

Retrieving Nazi Stolen Art? Here’s What You Should Know

Hans Sachs

The latest in a string of issues involving Nazi stolen art is making reverberations around the arts community, and once again prompting a discussion regarding the provenance and authenticity of historical works of art.

The collective artworks of Dr. Hans Sachs, a Jewish dentist, residing in Germany during the early 20th century, are coming up for sale at London auction house Christie’s. Sachs, an avid collector of graphic works of art, had over 12,000 posters and other objects in his collection. Christie’s is estimating that Sachs’ works – they’re auctioning just 100 posters from the entire collection – could be valued as much as a half million dollars, with the starting price of some works beginning at $1,150 and ranging up to $26,000 per piece.

So where does the issue lie? Like most art collectors living in Nazi Germany, Sachs was susceptible to the Fascist government. The Nazis seized Sach’s works, and in his lifetime he was unable to determine whether or not his collection remained intact. When they were finally found nearly 20 years after his death, his son embarked on a legal battle that recovered some, but not most, of the works. Here, we’ll discuss the various legal issues that have arisen throughout the case, and whether or not Sachs may still have a claim under certain areas of law.

A Legacy of Collecting Lost

Dr. Hans Sach was so passionate about the bold, graphic posters of the early 20th century that he formed a collecting society in Berlin and published an international poster magazine. His collection inevitably grew by thousands, and included some of the greatest graphic artists of the generation, including Egon Schiele, Alfred Roller, and Koloman Moser.

Nazi Stolen Art
A Sample of Hans Sachs’ Poster Collection

 

In 1939, during a Nazi raid that’s known as the Night of the Broken Glass, Sachs was arrested by the Gestapo and sent to prison, and his poster collection seized. Though he wouldn’t remain imprisoned for very long, he would never see his poster collection again.

When Sachs was released, he left with his family to the United States, where he would remain until his death in 1974. In 1961, he managed to petition for restitution fo his works under the German Restitution Act, which permitted German citizens to recover monetary damages for artworks and other items stolen under the fascist government. Sachs was awarded approximately $50,000 for his collection, believing that his beloved poster collection was either destroyed or gone forever.

Years later, his son would come across information that the collection was in the possession of the German Historical Museum. By doing a simple Google search, Peter Sachs realized that his father’s collection was still salvageable

Accounts differ as to whether Sachs found out about his beloved collection’s existence before his death in 1974, but decades later, his son stumbled across a reference to the archive in the German Historical Museum (DHM) during an online search. When his initial request for the return of the works was denied, Sachs set out to prove his rightful ownership in court. While Sachs and the Museum settled in a manner that proved favorable for Sachs, there are two important areas of law that need to be understood and visited.

Understanding the Issues Involved in Retrieving Stolen Art

In order to determine whether or not Sachs is entitled to the collection, he must prove that the collection actually did belong to his father. In the art world, proof of authenticity and ownership is considered the work’s provenance – provenance essentially determines the work’s origin and whether or not it is truly an authentic piece of art.

According to the International Foundation for Art Research, the provenance of a work of art is “a historical record of its ownership and an indicator of economic and market conditions influencing the sale or transfer of the work of art.” An ideal provenance history would provide a documentary record of owners’ names; dates of ownership, and means of transference, i.e. inheritance, or sale through a dealer or auction; and locations where the work was kept, from the time of its creation by the artist until the present day. Unfortunately, such complete, unbroken records of ownership are rare, and most works of art contain gaps in provenance. Likewise, proving provenance on German art recovered from the early 20th century is even harder because few documents remain that would support a claim.

Luckily, Sachs was a prolific poster collector and left a paper trail of his involvement with enough witnesses to back up his reputation as one of the world’s foremost poster collectors. But what would need to be done to prove the provenance of lesser-known, more obscure collectors’ art collection given the difficulties in obtaining supporting documents?

Nazi Stolen Art and The Foreign Sovereign Immunity Act

Sachs was able to achieve the desired outcome of his case without having to resort to the Foreign Sovereign Immunity Act, but the tactic would have been a clever argument had he not achieved such a positive result. We’ve previously discussed FSIA in the context of Nazi stolen art when we gave a legal overview of how Marie Altmann, niece of Adele Bloch-Bauer, was successfully able to recover Gustav Klimt’s “The Woman in Gold” from an Austrian state museum.

Under the FSIA, foreign states are presumed to be immune from the jurisdiction of U.S. courts and liability in US lawsuits unless the property was taken in violation of international law, and fell within one of the several exceptions.  The “expropriation exception,” allows a foreign state to be sued over a property located in the foreign state and the property holder engaged in a commercial activity in the United States.  To prevail on the FSIA, then, one must show that the entity subject to the suit is somehow engaging in commercial activity in the U.S, as noted by the FSIA below:

[T]he issue is whether the particular actions that the foreign state performs (whatever the motive behind them) are the type of actions by which a private party engages in “trade and traffic or commerce” …. (See Republic of Argentina v. Weltover, Inc., 504 U.S. 607, 614, 112 S. Ct. 2160 (1992).)

Foreign states, their agencies, and other state-owned enterprises are often engaged in transnational commercial activities in foreign countries, such as energy exploration, mining, banking, maritime and aerial transportation, and tourism, to name just a few. In the case of “Woman in Gold,” the court found that marketing of exhibitions in the United States was enough to show grounds for an FSIA claim.

Once it can be shown that an entity is engaged in such commercial activity, the claimant has to demonstrate that the FSIA should apply retroactively, which won’t always be easy to do. In Nazi art cases, this will usually turn on whether the entity had knowledge of the fact that works were stolen. This can be proven rather easily when there’s a claim for restitution filed: if the owner of the art didn’t miss it or didn’t find it valuable, it’s unlikely he would be petitioning the government for its retrieval or its compensation. That argument worked for Ms. Altmann, who paved the way for future Nazi stolen art cases. Thanks to her, retrieving Nazi stolen art, even in an absence of provenance, is just a little bit easier.

About the author

Nicole Martinez

Nicole is a writer and law school graduate with a dedicated focus and passion for the arts, and a particular interest in Latin American art and history. Nicole has extensive experience working with art galleries and museums in Buenos Aires and Miami, and explores cultural landscapes across the Americas through her writing.

You can e-mail Nicole at [email protected]

2 Comments

Click here to post a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • What are the limitations for retrieving art stolen during war time? Can a claim be made for works stolen during earlier wars in the century?

    • Unfortunately, thats hard to say. Every country has different laws and time limits. But if you have proof, I would contact an attorney specializing in stolen art and have a conversation. It’s a difficult topic and I am not an expert on this. Sorry I couldn’t help more.

Orangenius

We built Orangenius to help creators succeed. Our comprehensive platform takes the guesswork out of the business of art, so you can focus on creating. Click to see how Orangenius is revolutionizing the creative economy.

JOIN FOR FREE

The Latest From Artrepreneur

  • A Recruiter’s Advice for your Video or Motion Design Reel

    Creative Circle recruiter Brooks Rowlett sifts through hundreds of motion design reels and video editor portfolios each week. Here, he shares his best advice for motion designers and video editors looking to land their next big gig. The post A […]

  • From Tattoo Artist to Brand Empire: The Rise of the Ink Mogul

    The savvy tattoo artist uses brand recognition to launch a multimedia business. These four artists have leveraged their underground celebrity status to build a brand empire, complete with product lines, book deals, and TV contracts. The post From […]

  • Exploring the Intersection of Art and Technology

    The advent of technology is re-shaping the practice of art. These educational institutions, artists, and startups are exploring art and technology's convergence in today's increasingly digital world. The post Exploring the Intersection of Art and […]

  • Work with an Artist Mentor to Get Your Career on Track

    Many of the world's most recognized artists sought inspiration and guidance from their peers. Gain insight into your practice and learn about the business of art by finding an artist mentor whose career aligns with your own vision for success. The […]

  • Why Artists Need to Make Copyright Registration a Priority

    Sharing, posting, and distributing your work online is easier than ever - but often times, visual artists find themselves dealing with online piracy issues as a result of that practice. Initiating a copyright registration routine can curb the […]

  • How Artists on Social Media Can Grow Their Following

    By sticking to the tenets of the social media pyramid, artists on social media can develop an engaged audience. The post How Artists on Social Media Can Grow Their Following appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • How [and Where] to Submit an Art Fair Application

    Submitting an art fair application doesn't have to be an arduous process. We break down which fairs are currently accepting submissions, and how you should apply. The post How [and Where] to Submit an Art Fair Application appeared first on […]

  • The Paperwork Behind Your Art Business [Part I]

    In this ongoing series, we'll review the various documents needed to get your art business up and running. First up: Crafting your artist proposal. The post The Paperwork Behind Your Art Business [Part I] appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • A Creative Career Coach Outlines a Strategy for the Working Artist

    Marc Zegans coaches artists planning the next move in their art careers. Here, he shares his proven approach for developing your practice as a working artist. The post A Creative Career Coach Outlines a Strategy for the Working Artist appeared first […]

  • How One Artist Uses Instagram to Land Consistent Illustration Gigs

    Illustrator Maria Luque's secret to landing a steady stream of illustration gigs? Just be consistent and post regularly on Instagram. The post How One Artist Uses Instagram to Land Consistent Illustration Gigs appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • Artists Who Failed – And Found Success Anyway

    Some of the world's most successful artists weren't always so revered. Meet five artists who failed to develop their art careers during their lifetime. The post Artists Who Failed – And Found Success Anyway appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • How Do Online Content Moderation Policies Treat Nudity in Art?

    As Facebook's online content moderation policies come under fire, we review creative platform Orangenius' policy on nudity in art. The post How Do Online Content Moderation Policies Treat Nudity in Art? appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • Self Employed? Five Ways To Get Into the Creative Habit

    Self-employed artists don't always leave room for inspiration. Boost productivity and get into the creative habit with these proven strategies. The post Self Employed? Five Ways To Get Into the Creative Habit appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • A Creative in a Corporate Organization: Related Group’s Art Department

    In this ongoing series, we explore the creative roles available in the most unlikely of corporations. Our first installment talks to Patricia Hanna, the Art Director of Related Group. The post A Creative in a Corporate Organization: Related […]

  • Five Alternative Income Strategies for Independent Artists

    Independent artists shouldn't have to go hungry. We explore five alternative income streams to keep your art business on track. The post Five Alternative Income Strategies for Independent Artists appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]