Home | Industry | Parody, Fair Use, and Kiss My Ass

Parody, Fair Use, and Kiss My Ass

Leonardo Hidalgo

We talk a lot about copyright infringement on this site, but not every use of someone else’s work is an infringement. Copyright is subject to certain limitations found in the Copyright Act.  One of the more important limitations is the doctrine of  “fair use.” This doctrine was developed through the courts over the years and eventually codified into the statute.

The Copyright Act actually contains a list of the various purposes for which copying a work may be considered fair, including criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Other fair use situations are not as clear-cut. To decide whether a work is fair use, courts look at a balance of four factors:

  1. The purpose and character of the use, including whether such use is of a commercial nature or is for nonprofit educational purposes;
  2. The nature of the copyrighted work;
  3. The amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole; and
  4. The effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work.

17 U.S.C. § 107.

Each factor should be explored and weighed on a case-by-case basis, and depending on the facts of the case, some factors may weigh more heavily than others. See Campbell v. Acuff-Rose Music, Inc.

There is one fair use area however, that the Supreme Court has decided requires additional factors to determine fair use; Parody.  The reason for this is that parody and satire are closely intertwined but parody is considered fair use, while satire is not. So what is the difference and when is can an artist safely claim their work as parody?

First, lets look at the basic definitions.  To be parody, the work must poke fun or mimic the original work but cannot use the work to poke fun at something else. Parody usually attempts to exaggerate something in a humorous way.  Satire on the other hand, exposes the subject to ridicule of some kind, usually with a point of view meant to provoke or prevent change. Satire can use any point of view. Satire’s goal is to be political, social, or moral and not overtly humorous. While Parody and satire can often overlap, should you be able to claim parody, then your use of copyrighted material is likely fair use.

Next, we must still apply the four factor listed above.  If the factors in combination weigh heavily against fair use, despite it being parody, an artist may have a problem.  The court also looks at these additional factors in its parody analysis

  1. the parody must be obvious: the audience should not have to struggle to figure out what is being made fun of.
  2. the parody must take no more of the original than necessary to make its point.  So changing just the words in a chorus of a popular song, while leaving the rest of the song intact, is likely not fair use.
  3. Finally, a parody cannot pose a direct threat to the market for the original work. Think of it this way, would people buy the parody instead of the original, cannibalizing sales of the original?

Lets look at an example.  Leonardo Hidalgo, a successful artist in Miami has a piece from his collection called, Kiss My Ass, seen here.  (for more work, go to leonardohidalgo.com554376_10151673323045319_708120318_24496363_1481276470_n-300x300

While using the well-known image of the Hershey’s Kiss, the work is clearly parody.  It makes fun of the Kiss, which is the subject.  The work does not use more than is necessary to make its point, anything less and you would not know it is a Kiss.  As well, it is obvious; you can figure out the meaning immediately.  It is not a political work attempting to change behavior or habits.  And finally, While the work is commercial in nature, sold as a painting, it does not pose a monetary threat to Hershey.

One caveat that readers should consider; just because you believe your work is fair use, doesn’t mean that someone won’t try to sue you anyway.  A person may feel that the work is not fair use, someone else may not be happy with their likeness used in that way, others may see dollar signs because your sales are huge. With success and exposure often come legal actions.  It’s sad but true.  Stick something on a Snapple bottle seen in every store in the U.S., and you will be more likely to find yourself in court.

As I have mentioned in other articles, one way to help protect yourself is by registering your copyright within the first three months of publication since that will potentially allow you to recoup attorney’s fees.  And, make it easier for an attorney to take the case on a contingency basis.

Again, if you find this useful, please share it on your social media. 

Enhanced by Zemanta

About the author

Steve Schlackman

As a photographer and Patent Attorney with a background in marketing, Steve has a unique perspective on art and law. Should you have any questions on Intellectual Property contact him at [email protected] His photography can be seen online at Fotofilosophy.com or on display at the Emmanuel Fremin Gallery in New York City.

1 Comment

Click here to post a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

{{Privy:Embed campaign=133844}}

The Latest From Artrepreneur

  • A Guide to Eliminating Artist Debt and Sticking to a Budget

    The average working artist faces student loans and other debt. We ask several financial experts how they coach artists through managing artist debt while budgeting for their creative business.The post A Guide to Eliminating Artist Debt and Sticking […]

  • This CERF+ Workshop Will Teach Artists to Manage Risk

    This week, CERF+ will host a workshop for Gatlinburg artists. "Ready and Resilient" will cover topics in disaster preparedness along with a host of others focused around managing an art business.The post This CERF+ Workshop Will Teach Artists to […]

  • Jeffrey Deitch Reveals His Secrets to Sell Art

    [email protected] and Orangenius present an interview with Jeffrey Deitch, a pervasive figure in the world of contemporary art. Listen to the full podcast here.The post Jeffrey Deitch Reveals His Secrets to Sell Art appeared first on […]

  • How to Attract the Right Artist Opportunities

    While being selected for the right artist opportunities can feel like a murky process, there are straightforward ways to move forward with advancing your career with help from your artist network.The post How to Attract the Right Artist […]

  • 10 Interview Questions Artists Must Be Able to Answer

    If you've secured that important sit-down with a potential collector, arts journalist, or gallerist, be prepared to answer these common artist interview questions during your initial meeting.The post 10 Interview Questions Artists Must Be Able to […]

  • Secured a Studio Visit? Here’s How to Keep Your Visitor Hooked

    Artists often underestimate the importance of follow-up after an artist studio visit. Here's how to wow curators, art critics, and collectors that made the time to visit your space.The post Secured a Studio Visit? Here’s How to Keep Your […]

  • Artists are Partnering with Independent Designers, Retail Brands

    Artists and graphic designers are breaking into fashion graphic design by collaborating with independent designers and fast fashion brands. We talk to two designers on these increasingly prevalent partnerships.The post Artists are Partnering with […]

  • How An Estate Tax Repeal Might Affect the Art World

    A GOP repeal of the estate tax could produce a chilling effect on art museum donations while creating a bump in the art market. Here's why private art collectors may be less inclined to donate art.The post How An Estate Tax Repeal Might Affect the […]

  • 3 Common Pitfalls to Avoid in a Photography Contract

    A photography contract that doesn't consider art licensing rights and work made for hire agreements can have a significant impact on a photographer's business. Here are the common pitfalls photographers need to avoid.The post 3 Common Pitfalls to […]

  • These Creative Apps Can Help You Find Inspiration

    Last week we tackled 8 essential creative apps to simplify your creative business. Here, we’ll be diving into the best mobile apps to keep you constantly inspired.The post These Creative Apps Can Help You Find Inspiration appeared first on […]