Home | Business | Who Owns Works Created by a Freelancer?
Business Copyright

Who Owns Works Created by a Freelancer?

Work made for hire in copyright

As a general rule, when an artistic or literary work is created, the author is the one that holds the copyright. Nobody can copy, distribute, or display the work without the author’s permission.  When a painting is sold, the buyer owns the painting itself, but does not have the right to use that image for anything else other than to hang it. But what happens if the artist was hired specifically to create that painting for the cover of an upcoming novel?  In some cases, the copyright is owned by the buyer, but only under very specific conditions.

Copyright for a freelancer

For the hiring party to own a copyright on a specially ordered or freelance work, there must be:

  1. a written agreement signed by both parties
  2. that specifically states that the work is a work made for hire.
  3. and, the work must be one of these nine categories of creative works:
    1. a contribution to a collective work,
    2. part of a motion picture or other audiovisual work,
    3. a translation,
    4. a supplementary work,
    5. a compilation,
    6. an instructional text,
    7. a test,
    8. answer material for a test,
    9. or an atlas.

While this may seems simple, most people are not aware of these requirements and therefore, the agreement between the parties is often faulty.

As well, notice that visual arts or literary authorship are not specifically mentioned on the category list, and so even with a signed agreement stating the work is a work made for hire, the artist or author may still hold the copyright. For example, if an artist is hired to paint a wall mural for an office building, that is clearly a work of visual art, so despite a work made for hire agreement, the artist retains the copyright. On the other hand, a graphic designer signing a work made for hire agreement to create an original work for the cover of a magazine may not hold the copyright because the work may be considered a “contribution to a collective work.”

The reason I say, “may not hold the copyright,” is that the definition of a collective work is not universally defined.   Whether a work falls into one of the nine categories depends on several factors, including how the court in that Federal District has defined the term in the past, or what the industry standard may be when hiring freelancers.  Specifically stating the work is a work made for hire may be enough, but to avoid any confusion, it is best to spell out which of the nine categories the work falls under. In this case, the contract may state, “this agreement is considered a work made for hire as a contribution to a collective work.  All copyright in the work, therefore, is held by . . . “, or something to that effect.

Without specific requirements made in writing, the hiring party will not own own the work they commissioned?

If the author retains the copyright in a commissioned work, then all that the hiring party receives is limited license for its use consisting of whatever rights the author assigns.  Even without work made for hire language where the copyright is to be maintained by the author, those rights should still be spelled out in a written agreement to avoid confusion.  Let’s say a videographer develops a 30-second commercial for Company X, which the company intends to show in their local market, Atlanta. The videographer and Company X sign an agreement but it is not a work made for hire and there is no dispute that the videographer holds the copyright in the commercial.  The agreement allows Company X to run the commercial for 3 months before an additional license fee is required. The commercial runs for 2 months in Atlanta, but then, for the remaining month, Company X starts showing the commercial in 10 major cities around the country as part of a national expansion campaign.  The videographer was told the commercial would show only in Atlanta. The videographer feels he should receive an additional licensing fee for showing the commercial nationally, but would find it difficult to sue without having specified the terms in the agreement.

These are small examples, but lawsuits around copyright ownership of works made for hire are common.  Fortunately, problems can be easily avoided by following the rules mentioned here.  Just make sure that both parties are aware of the rules so there is no question that both parties fully understood the terms upon signing.

Please share this post so we can make sure your friends and colleagues know the rules also. 

About the author

Steve Schlackman

As a photographer and Patent Attorney with a background in marketing, Steve has a unique perspective on art and law. Should you have any questions on Intellectual Property contact him at steve@orangenius.com. His photography can be seen online at Fotofilosophy.com or on display at the Emmanuel Fremin Gallery in New York City.

Add Comment

Click here to post a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

{{Privy:Embed campaign=133844}}

The Latest From Artrepreneur

  • Follow This Foolproof Approach to Curating Your Creative Portfolio

    Hiring managers pay more attention to the contents of your creative portfolio than your work experience. Artrepreneur reviews proven strategies for curating a creative portfolio that lands you that coveted gig. The post Follow This Foolproof […]

  • The Essential Guide to Writing Your Artist Statement

    Used in combination with your artist CV, your artist statement is an opportunity to hook the reader and get them interested in exploring your work. Follow this step-by-step guide to craft your professional artist statement. The post The Essential […]

  • Show-and-Sell: Six Alternative Representation Strategies for Artists

    Artists don’t need gallery representation to make sales and gain followers. Artrepreneur investigates six alternative representation strategies for artists looking to expand their audience. The post Show-and-Sell: Six Alternative […]

  • How to Build An Artist Network to Kickstart Your Career

    To develop their careers, art students should build an artist network that leverages their talent and skill set with opportunities to show their work. Follow these strategic tips to build a meaningful network. The post How to Build An Artist Network […]

  • How Should I Structure My Artist CV Layout?

    The artist CV is an essential tool when dealing with galleries and potential collectors determining whether to invest in your work. Artrepreneur explains how to structure an attention-grabbing artist CV layout. The post How Should I Structure My […]

  • Are You an Art Major? Nine Art Related Jobs to Pursue

    From art critic to interior designer, an art major weighing various art related jobs or career paths has plenty of options to consider. Artrepreneur explores some of the most popular career paths taken by art school graduates. The post Are You an […]

  • The ‘Shared Economy’ Artist Collective: Should Artists Pay for Exhibition Space?

    The artist collective is evolving in the shared economy. In exchange for a membership or exhibition fee, artists have the opportunity to present their work in a 'shared' exhibition space. Artrepreneur investigates whether this model makes sense for […]

  • How Can I Fund Art Exhibitions and Other Projects? [Part II]

    Aside from more traditional financing models such as arts grants or crowdfunding, pairing up with art partners is an excellent way to fund art exhibitions and other projects. Artrepreneur takes a look at the various partnership arrangements […]

  • Launching a Creative Business? Design A Logo That Hooks

    Designing an impactful logo for your creative business involves a careful reflection of your brand strategy. Whether you're designing your own logo or working with a professional, these two art directors offer their best advice for designing a logo […]

  • Ten Creative Internships for Aspiring Designers

    Creative internships will help you build the foundation you need for a career in the art world. Whether you're interested in design or web development, these are some of the most coveted – and most rewarding – creative internships out […]