Home | Copyright | George Zimmerman in trouble with the AP over his new painting
Copyright Industry

George Zimmerman in trouble with the AP over his new painting

George Zimmerman painting

Apparently, George Zimmerman is known for more than the shooting of Trayvon Martin; he is also a successful artist. His last painting sold on eBay for $100,000. Zimmerman’s new work, as shown above, depicts Florida State Attorney Angela Corey, who charged Zimmerman with the second-degree murder of Trayvon Martin.  The AP says that Zimmerman used their photo, shown below, as the basis for his painting. George Zimmerman probably has a good “fair use” defense, but that doesn’t mean he has an easy road ahead. Here’s why.

George Zimmerman Copyright Infringement

First, fair use is a defense, which only comes into play after a lawsuit is initiated. Despite how much someone believes his or her use of another’s copyrighted work is fair, there is no definitive rule on what constitutes fair use. We can only use rule as per the Copyright Act as a guide. Generally, using another’s creative work can be considered fair use if changes are made to the work that are considered transformative. What you are probably thinking is “how do I know if my work is transformative? You are not alone. Millions of dollars are spent every year fighting over that question.

Courts use a four-factor balancing test to determine whether a work constitutes fair use but let’s leave that test to the lawyers. What we need is a simple, practical definition that is easy to use. The Center for Social Media at American University have looked at the trends in court cases and collapsed the 4 factors down to two simple questions:

(1)  Does the new work add value to and repurpose the work for a new audience?

(2)  Is the amount of material that was used, appropriate to achieve the transformation?

Using no more of someone else’s work than necessary is an important consideration in surviving the fair use analysis.

So let’s look at Zimmerman’s work. He clearly used the AP photo to create his work.  And just because it is painted, that doesn’t make it transformative.  However, the photo was taken at a press conference for the Trayvon Martin case, and Zimmerman’s has turned the original photos intent on its head but reframing its meaning.  Is this enough to be considered transformative?  Also, while Zimmerman used the entire photo to create his new work, could his message been achieve with less of the photo? Therein lies the problem for Zimmerman.

Using another’s creative work can be considered fair use if changes are made to the work that are considered transformative.

Even if Zimmerman believes he has a strong case for fair use, he still has to prove it.  The AP has greater resources than Zimmerman.  They can push this case along if they feel that his case is weak.  That could cost Zimmerman a lot in legal fees. At this point, he could remove the painting from sale which might make the AP back off. Right now, we will just have to wait and see if the AP initiates a suit.

The important message for anyone using other people’s work is that fair use cannot stop someone from suing you.  From a practical point of view, the more exposure your fair use works gets (and the more money the work is worth), the more likely it is that a copyright holder will sue. So, if you are an artist who uses someone else’s work for your new pillow collection at Target, a cease-and-desist later may be in your future.

About the author

Steve Schlackman

As a photographer and Patent Attorney with a background in marketing, Steve has a unique perspective on art and law. Should you have any questions on Intellectual Property contact him at steve@orangenius.com. His photography can be seen online at Fotofilosophy.com or on display at the Emmanuel Fremin Gallery in New York City.

Add Comment

Click here to post a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

{{Privy:Embed campaign=133844}}

The Latest From Artrepreneur

  • How to Implement a Powerful Art Marketing Strategy

    How can artists implement an art marketing plan that’s both measurable and effective? Artrepreneur reviews some proven marketing strategies for artists.The post How to Implement a Powerful Art Marketing Strategy appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • A Guide to Eliminating Artist Debt and Sticking to a Budget

    The average working artist faces student loans and other debt. We ask several financial experts how they coach artists through managing artist debt while budgeting for their creative business.The post A Guide to Eliminating Artist Debt and Sticking […]

  • This CERF+ Workshop Will Teach Artists to Manage Risk

    This week, CERF+ will host a workshop for Gatlinburg artists. "Ready and Resilient" will cover topics in disaster preparedness along with a host of others focused around managing an art business.The post This CERF+ Workshop Will Teach Artists to […]

  • Jeffrey Deitch Reveals His Secrets to Sell Art

    Knowledge@Wharton and Orangenius present an interview with Jeffrey Deitch, a pervasive figure in the world of contemporary art. Listen to the full podcast here.The post Jeffrey Deitch Reveals His Secrets to Sell Art appeared first on […]

  • How to Attract the Right Artist Opportunities

    While being selected for the right artist opportunities can feel like a murky process, there are straightforward ways to move forward with advancing your career with help from your artist network.The post How to Attract the Right Artist […]

  • 10 Interview Questions Artists Must Be Able to Answer

    If you've secured that important sit-down with a potential collector, arts journalist, or gallerist, be prepared to answer these common artist interview questions during your initial meeting.The post 10 Interview Questions Artists Must Be Able to […]

  • Secured a Studio Visit? Here’s How to Keep Your Visitor Hooked

    Artists often underestimate the importance of follow-up after an artist studio visit. Here's how to wow curators, art critics, and collectors that made the time to visit your space.The post Secured a Studio Visit? Here’s How to Keep Your […]

  • Artists are Partnering with Independent Designers, Retail Brands

    Artists and graphic designers are breaking into fashion graphic design by collaborating with independent designers and fast fashion brands. We talk to two designers on these increasingly prevalent partnerships.The post Artists are Partnering with […]

  • How An Estate Tax Repeal Might Affect the Art World

    A GOP repeal of the estate tax could produce a chilling effect on art museum donations while creating a bump in the art market. Here's why private art collectors may be less inclined to donate art.The post How An Estate Tax Repeal Might Affect the […]

  • 3 Common Pitfalls to Avoid in a Photography Contract

    A photography contract that doesn't consider art licensing rights and work made for hire agreements can have a significant impact on a photographer's business. Here are the common pitfalls photographers need to avoid.The post 3 Common Pitfalls to […]