Home | Copyright | Some Copyright Holders Are Ridiculous
Copyright Industry

Some Copyright Holders Are Ridiculous

Phoenix Copyright Notice

While it is a good idea to enforce your copyright against unscrupulous Internet thieves, some copyright holders overreach their authority to their own detriment. Take the French Band “Phoenix,” and their label Liberation Music, who threatened to sue one of the most famous and well-respected copyright attorneys in the world; Harvard Professor Larry Lessig.

Our story begins with a lecture Lessig gave on ways copyright law needs to adapt to the Internet age. In his lecture, he shows examples of artists who share their culture and remix other people’s creations.  One of the examples he shows is a series of remixes using Phoenix’s song “Lisztomania”.  Someone had remixed that song with clips from the iconic ’80s movie The Breakfast Club.  The remix went viral. As you might expect, this inspired other videos, of which Lessig showed more examples. His lecture was posted to YouTube.

YouTube has a software robot that scans posted videos for copyrighted songs.  According to NPR, “many labels and artists have agreed to let songs stay up in return for a cut of the money that YouTube gets from ads it runs with the videos — but some labels, like Melbourne-based Liberation Music, which owns the rights to “Lisztomania,” just want them taken down.

Liberation Music sent a letter to YouTube asking for Lessig’s video to be removed. In order to ensure that they are not embroiled in a copyright lawsuit, YouTube follows the provisions of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), which provide a “safe harbor” for sites that have a DMCA registration and promptly remove offending works at the request of a copyright holder. So YouTube removed the lecture. However, the DMCA also says that if the uploader disagrees with the copyright holder as to whether the work is infinging, the online site can repost the material, pending the legal outcome between the copyright holder and the uploader. 

Lessig, being a very competent copyright attorney, was well aware that some uses of copyrighted material is considered “fair use” and not subject to legal action. The Copyright Act prescribes several activities as fair use; criticism, parody, news reporting, research, teaching, library archiving and scholarship, and critique or commentary. Lessig’s considered the use of the song as a critique and so a fair use.

 “If I’m using it for purposes of critique, then I can use if even if I don’t have permission of the original copyright owner,” he says.

Liberation backed down but Lessig didn’t let it go. He wanted a greater victory; for companies like Liberation Music to stop using automated systems to send takedown notices.

Takedown notices are extremely common across many types of Internet sites and in many cases, these companies are very aggressive, demanding exorbitant fees for the presumed offense. These notices are worded in way that will scare people into paying. Since few people don’t know their legal rights, they don’t know what actions to take. Also, the fees demanded are often less that required to hire an attorney. For example, one stock photography company will typically demand an $800 fee for unauthorized use of a stock photo. They go on to offer a discount, $450, if paid within 14 days, otherwise, the infringer will face legal action. With nobody to guide them on fighting back, people are forced to pay the ransom.

Lessig wanted that kind of extortion to stop, saying that these are “basically bad-faith lawsuits, . . . threats made fraudulently or without proper basis.” So he countersued and won.

In a statement, Liberation Music admitted Lessig’s use of the song was protected by fair use. The Company will also pay Lessig an undisclosed sum for the harm it caused,  all proceeds gong to the Electronic Frontier Foundation, a digital civil rights group, who defends digital rights. Liberation Music also agreed to adopt new policies around issuing takedown notices.

Lessig said in his own statement; “Too often copyright is used as an excuse to silence legitimate speech. I’ve been fighting against that kind of abuse for many years, and I knew I had to stand up for fair use here as well. Hopefully, this lawsuit will send a message to copyright owners to adopt fair takedown practices — or face the consequences.”

A better understanding of copyright law and a little common sense by Liberation Music, could have avoided this multi-year battle. Maybe Lessig’s actions will make companies review their automated takedown procedures, or at least very least, alert people in similar situations that they can fight back.

Please repost this to your social media so we can get the word out. 

About the author

Steve Schlackman

As a photographer and Patent Attorney with a background in marketing, Steve has a unique perspective on art and law. Should you have any questions on Intellectual Property contact him at [email protected] His photography can be seen online at Fotofilosophy.com or on display at the Emmanuel Fremin Gallery in New York City.

Add Comment

Click here to post a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

{{Privy:Embed campaign=133844}}

The Latest From Artrepreneur

  • The Educators Molding the Modern-Day Art Entrepreneur

    Struggling to develop the skills necessary to thrive as an art entrepreneur? Educators at the Society for Arts Entrepreneurship Education conference may have some solutions. The post The Educators Molding the Modern-Day Art Entrepreneur appeared […]

  • How Mickey Mouse Keeps Changing Copyright Law

    Copyright duration keeps getting longer, primarily due to Disney wanting to keep Mickey Mouse under copyright protection. Here's how they did it. The post How Mickey Mouse Keeps Changing Copyright Law appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • The Artist’s Guide to Creating a Media Kit

    An artist media kit is a useful tool for getting journalists and art critics to your exhibitions. We review what you should include when creating a media kit. The post The Artist’s Guide to Creating a Media Kit appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • You Don’t Need an MFA to Make It as An Artist

    While obtaining an MFA is the pathway some artists take to further pursue their career, it’s not always a crucial part of developing a distinct and successful artistic practice. The post You Don’t Need an MFA to Make It as An Artist […]

  • When [and Where] to Participate in an Art Exhibition

    Until an artist’s studio has significant resources, it may be difficult to participate in every single art exhibition. Artrepreneur outlines the benefits and drawbacks to consider when weighing local, regional, and international shows. The […]

  • How Do We Calculate the Value of Art?

    Many working artists struggle to price their work. From considering costs and materials to the artist's standing in the marketplace, how does the art world calculate the value of art? The post How Do We Calculate the Value of Art? appeared first on […]

  • The Art of Juggling: Mastering Time Management for Artists

    From designing to pitching, reporting to researching, creatives helming their own practice know that perfecting time management in their workflow produces real results. The post The Art of Juggling: Mastering Time Management for Artists appeared […]

  • Nic Bothma on Photojournalism in a Post-Digital Age

    Award-winning photojournalist Nic Bothma rose to acclaim photographing South African news stories in the 1990s. Here, he discusses how aspiring photographers should approach their business with the rise of camera phones and social media. The post […]

  • Five Art World Headliners on Developing Their Creative Careers

    What are some of the most critical challenges facing emerging artists today? Artrepreneur talks to five art world wunderkinds on what it takes to develop rewarding creative careers. The post Five Art World Headliners on Developing Their Creative […]

  • The End of Advertising? Tribeca Film Festival’s Andrew Essex Weighs In

    In the third installment of the Business of Art radio series, Tribeca Enterprises CEO Andrew Essex discusses the evolution of advertising and storytelling within the creative industries. The post The End of Advertising? Tribeca Film Festival’s […]