Home | Copyright | Did American Eagle Rip Off a Miami Street Artist?
Copyright

Did American Eagle Rip Off a Miami Street Artist?

AholSniffsGlue

Graffiti or Street Art has come a long way since the raw style adorning New York Subways or marking gang territories in the 1970’s. Street artists have gained a healthy following of fans enamored by their non-traditional approach to shape and color; an aesthetic highlighting socially relevant themes that appeal to a demographic that shuns the ordered and mundane art of the traditional gallery. In blighted areas, such as Miami’s Wynwood Art District, street art transforms a once bleak, treeless landscape of urban decay, into a hip and trendy neighborhood filled with the hottest restaurants, bars and art galleries.

Wynwood is a model of graffiti art featuring grandiose murals by some of Miami’s most prominent artists, including AholSniffsGlue (David Anasagasti), the best street artist of 2014 according to the Miami New Times. Known for his anti-corporate message, Ahol focuses on ‘the veneer of our everyday surroundings and the dull, job-related conflicts often encountered in a dysfunctional workplace.’ So when Ahol discovered that international clothing giant American Eagle Outfitters (AEO) was using his work in its new ad campaign, without his authorization, attribution or compensation, he took action and filed a lawsuit for copyright infringement.

At issue are several photos showing Ahol’s murals as the backdrop for AEO’s spring marketing campaign. The infringing photos allegedly appear in many types of media, including the AEO website, various social media sites, billboards, advertisements, and on in-store displays, in cities across the United States, Colombia, Panama, and Japan. One billboard shows a male model leaping over a fire hydrant in front of what appears to be Mr Anasagasti’s Ocean Grown mural, commissioned by Miami’s Ocean Grown Glass Gallery. In another photo, a model holds a blue spray paint can, implying that this “young, clean-cut and apparently Caucasian model was the creator of ‘Ocean Grown,’” according to the complaint. (Anasagasti is in fact a bearded, heavily-tattooed, and Cuban-American.)

Street Art
© Giulio Sclorio

It seems a bit odd that a major company like AEO would make such an egregious error. The complaint states that the company had Ansagasti’s personal information yet never made any attempt to reach him. Rather than being an error, maybe AEO believed that getting permission wasn’t necessary?  The problem is that the law is not settled on this issue.

It seems a bit odd that a major company like AEO would make such an egregious error. The complaint states that the company had Ansagasti’s personal information yet never made any attempt to reach him. Rather than being an error, maybe AEO believed that getting permission wasn’t necessary?  The problem is that the law is not settled on this issue.

The uncertainty perhaps has made some companies a little bold. On the one hand, any street art should receive copyright protection. Copyright protection is available for “any original work of authorship that is fixed in any tangible medium of expression.” However, courts and commentators have suggested that illegal work is not subject to copyright protection because a work must be free from illegality. The basis for this requirement is that no one should profit from his or her wrongs.

Some would say that street artists are nothing more than vandals intent on defacing private property.  Creating works without the property owner’s permission does open up the artist to criminal charges of vandalism or trespass, depending upon the local laws. The risk keeps most street artists from claiming copyright infringement.

Even Banksy, one of the most polar street artists today, keeps his identity secret in the pursuit of his art. Banksy’s work is reproduced without fear of being embroiled in a copyright infringement lawsuit. Even sales of his original works hasn’t brought Banksy out into the open. In 2013, “Slave Labour,” a Banksy mural behind a discount shop in London, was sold at a private auction for $1.1 million. His anonymity has served Banksy well, especially given the New York Police desire to “question him in connection with the vandalism. If they catch him, he will be charged with vandalism.” Given the risk, it is not surprising that so few graffiti related copyright infringement cases make it to court. Those few cases that are filed have ended in a settlement, without legal weight.

Street Art at American Eagle

This case then has the potential to write new law, assuming the parties don’t settle this case first. How the case will turn out is hard to say, but one part of the U.S. Copyright Statute that may have some bearing. Although the Statute does not say explicitly that illegal work is un-copyrightable, it does exclude copyright protection for compilations and derivative works that use copyrighted material unlawfully. By leaving out similar language for original works, Congress may have indicated its intent to allow copyright in any creative work that is fixed in a tangible medium; created by illegal means or not.

What do you think about street art and copyright protection? Let us know. For more detailed information on this case, the complaint is provided below.

*Please note that while some press articles have said that Anasagasti’s works were commissioned, nothing in the complaint indicates such. So this article is written with the belief that Anasagasti had no permission from the property owner when creating his murals.

About the author

Steve Schlackman

As a photographer and Patent Attorney with a background in marketing, Steve has a unique perspective on art and law. Should you have any questions on Intellectual Property contact him at steve@orangenius.com. His photography can be seen online at Fotofilosophy.com or on display at the Emmanuel Fremin Gallery in New York City.

1 Comment

Click here to post a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • This brings us a question that you haven’t addressed. Street art is deliberately created in public spaces for public viewing. How does that effect copyright? Does that mean photographers have to get permission or a release for every building, sculpture, person that may subject or background in their photographs?

{{Privy:Embed campaign=133844}}

The Latest From Artrepreneur

  • How to Implement a Powerful Art Marketing Strategy

    How can artists implement an art marketing plan that’s both measurable and effective? Artrepreneur reviews some proven marketing strategies for artists.The post How to Implement a Powerful Art Marketing Strategy appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • A Guide to Eliminating Artist Debt and Sticking to a Budget

    The average working artist faces student loans and other debt. We ask several financial experts how they coach artists through managing artist debt while budgeting for their creative business.The post A Guide to Eliminating Artist Debt and Sticking […]

  • This CERF+ Workshop Will Teach Artists to Manage Risk

    This week, CERF+ will host a workshop for Gatlinburg artists. "Ready and Resilient" will cover topics in disaster preparedness along with a host of others focused around managing an art business.The post This CERF+ Workshop Will Teach Artists to […]

  • Jeffrey Deitch Reveals His Secrets to Sell Art

    Knowledge@Wharton and Orangenius present an interview with Jeffrey Deitch, a pervasive figure in the world of contemporary art. Listen to the full podcast here.The post Jeffrey Deitch Reveals His Secrets to Sell Art appeared first on […]

  • How to Attract the Right Artist Opportunities

    While being selected for the right artist opportunities can feel like a murky process, there are straightforward ways to move forward with advancing your career with help from your artist network.The post How to Attract the Right Artist […]

  • 10 Interview Questions Artists Must Be Able to Answer

    If you've secured that important sit-down with a potential collector, arts journalist, or gallerist, be prepared to answer these common artist interview questions during your initial meeting.The post 10 Interview Questions Artists Must Be Able to […]

  • Secured a Studio Visit? Here’s How to Keep Your Visitor Hooked

    Artists often underestimate the importance of follow-up after an artist studio visit. Here's how to wow curators, art critics, and collectors that made the time to visit your space.The post Secured a Studio Visit? Here’s How to Keep Your […]

  • Artists are Partnering with Independent Designers, Retail Brands

    Artists and graphic designers are breaking into fashion graphic design by collaborating with independent designers and fast fashion brands. We talk to two designers on these increasingly prevalent partnerships.The post Artists are Partnering with […]

  • How An Estate Tax Repeal Might Affect the Art World

    A GOP repeal of the estate tax could produce a chilling effect on art museum donations while creating a bump in the art market. Here's why private art collectors may be less inclined to donate art.The post How An Estate Tax Repeal Might Affect the […]

  • 3 Common Pitfalls to Avoid in a Photography Contract

    A photography contract that doesn't consider art licensing rights and work made for hire agreements can have a significant impact on a photographer's business. Here are the common pitfalls photographers need to avoid.The post 3 Common Pitfalls to […]