Home | Copyright | Can an AI Machine Hold Copyright Protection Over Its Work?
Copyright

Can an AI Machine Hold Copyright Protection Over Its Work?

ai machine

With so much talk in the mainstream media centered on whether some jobs are becoming obsolete thanks to artificial intelligence, creators may now have to worry whether they, too, might be replaced by an AI machine.

The latest in a string of AI machine inventions aimed at the creative industries is aptly called “Bot Dylan” – a researcher developed program that’s able to generate new folk songs by using over 23,000 pieces of Irish folk music.

This new computerized composer is the brainchild of Dr. Oded Ben-Tal, a senior lecturer in music technology at Kingston University, who decided to use Celtic folk music for its wide breadth of sound. Using transcriptions of 23,000 folk tunes written in a common music notation form called ABC, the machine was able to recognize and master the patterns of a song. So far, Ben-Tal and his team have managed to create over 100,000 new folk songs by taking one ABC symbol and suggesting the next symbol that should follow, creating an entirely new song.

This isn’t the first AI machine of its class to create wholly original creative works – some time ago, we discussed a similar program that was able to recreate a Rembrandt painting by analyzing 350 works by the artist. If an AI machine can create a painting that reflects the caliber of a legendary artist like Rembrandt, than one really has to wonder whether the future of creativity lies in an algorithm – and if we’re considering that, than there’s a whole host of questions that we need to ask ourselves about the future of ownership and copyright protection in creative works.

Can AI Machine-Generated Creations Get Copyright Protection?

Copyright protection in creative works by an AI machine presents an interesting dichotomy for copyright scholars because the question of whether an AI machine’s work product can technically be considered protectable under copyright law is rather vague.

For most works of art, copyright protection is affixed the moment that work is created. That means that the creator of the work enjoys the sole, exclusive right to determine what’s done with that work – distribution, making copies, publicly performing the work – that’s all forbidden without the express permission of the author. However, when it comes to AI machine creations – like folk songs or a painting – then copyright protection isn’t so cut and dried, since there are a few creators involved in bringing this work to life. In our ‘Bot Dylan’ example, would copyright protection be afforded to Dr. Ben-Tal? His team of researchers? What about the creators of the songs the AI machine studied in order to create its own songs? Can the machine itself enjoy copyright protection? Can it’s owner?

copyright protection
AI machines are increasingly making creative works.

The answer is quite muddled, and in order to fully understand who owns the copyright in AI machine-created work, we need to take a close look at the Copyright Act, and determine whether the resulting work is even eligible for copyright protection.

According to the Act, copyright protection is available for 1) an original work of authorship, 2) fixed in a tangible medium 3) that has a minimal amount of creativity. If a work doesn’t have all three of these components, then it is not copyrightable subject matter.

Let’s start with an analysis of the first prong: is an AI machine-created work sufficiently original enough to be copyrightable? Originality is grounded on the idea that the resulting product is new or novel, and not a reproduction. But couldn’t it be argued that an AI machine isn’t creating anything original, just picking up on sound modules to string them along? Not necessarily. Copying a style isn’t the same as copying a work – and while an AI machine is using composites of sounds or paintings to generate original content, the reality is that these works remain original because they’ve never been heard before.

In addition, the researchers admittedly could not predict what the AI machine was going to create once they had mastered the ABC system for folk music. In fact, that’s why the team decided to use Celtic music, since it had so many notes and chords – they essentially gave the AI machine an extremely large canvas with which to work with, and couldn’t predict which notes or symbols they would use.

As a result, the AI machine’s process was sufficiently original enough to satisfy the originality prong of our analysis, since each song is wholly unique.

In addition, the work satisfies the ‘fixed in tangible medium’ component of our analysis because the work has entered the public conscious – the work exists for anyone to hear. Once the Ai bot’s algorithm comes into existence, it is considered to be fixed in a tangible medium, just as the same would be true for a poem written on napkin or a drawing on a sheet of looseleaf paper.

Perhaps the most controversial question is whether or not the AI machine’s work is creative enough to enjoy copyright protection. As humans, it’s difficult to consider that a machine can be intelligent enough to engage in creative thought – and copyright lawmakers have considered the issue in the writing of the law.

503.03(a) Works-not originated by a human author.

In order to be entitled to copyright registration, a work must be the product of human authorship. Works produced by mechanical processes or random selection without any contribution by a human author are not registrable.

So what does that interpretation of copyright law tell us? For one, it unequivocally states that a computer or an animal shouldn’t and can’t hold a copyright, and it makes sense when you think about the function and purpose of copyright law in the first place. Since the holder of a copyright has the sole ability to give permission to others to use and distribute their work, then a computer inherently can’t hold a copyright since it’s unable to express their intention when determining whether or not to do so. Not only can a computer not consent to something like that, it also can’t enforce those rights and prevent anyone from doing so without permission. Similar to the cotroversy over the ‘monkey selfie,’ in which PETA sued for copyright infringement on behalf of a monkey who took a photo of itself, which later wound up being shared across the internet. The monkey selfie lawsuit was deemed rather frivoulous, and it reinforced the notion that animals can’t hold copyright protection in a work. Computers, like monkeys, can’t go to court, after all.

But Someone Has to Own the Copyright in These Songs, Right?

If we’ve determined that these songs – though created by a computer – are original, fixed in a tangible medium, and a creative product – then we have to assign the copyright to someone, right? Not necessarily.

There are some works that enter the public domain the moment they’re created. For example, works or images created by the government are automatically rendered public, non-copyrightable images. In order to determine whether Bot Dylan’s songs would be copyrightable, we have to determine whether the researchers that fed the AI machine the songs would hold copyright protection in the resulting new songs created by the AI machine. But is that a stretch?

ai machine
Unless a creator had an extensive role in the AI machine’s work, they can’t seek copyright protection in the work.

The Supreme Court outlined their ideas of what constitutes ownership of a creative work by a computer in a 1973 court case, Goldstein v. California. There, the Court interpreted the authorship requirement to include “any physical rendering of the fruits of creative intellectual or aesthetic labor.” The Supreme Court reasoned that in most cases, in order for a computer to generate any kind of artistic work, there must be significant input from an author or user, and only then can the mastermind behind the AI machine hold copyright protection in the work.

A year later, Congress created the National Commission on New Technological Uses of Copyrighted Works (CONTU), which studied a variety of new technology issues, including the issue of authorship of computer-generated works. Although CONTU did not expound on the topic extensively, it did conclude that authorship rights should go to the user when the user makes a very substantial contribution to the output. But when the user does very little and most of the output is left up to the AI machine, then it is less likely that the user may own the copyright in the output. 

A great example of an instance in which copyright protection would exist in a creator rather than an AI machine is Photoshop. If you think about it, Photoshop is an algorithm – there’s software behind a designer’s ability to shape an image using Photoshop tools. However, the designer’s input is necessary to the final product – they’re the one deciding what will go where, and directing the algorithm to deploy their creation.

Courts will generally put a lot of emphasis on whether the researcher had any substantial input beyond the simple creation of an algorithm or process for which the computer generates creative work. For example, the Rembrandt example would be one such project in which the software developers could likely exert copyright protection over the artistic work, since there was likely a lot of creative thought behind the project. But could the same be true for the makers of Bot Dylan?

It’s hard to say. You see, the researchers that created the Bot Dylan AI machine didn’t exactly reinvent the wheel – they didn’t create a new algorithm, but rather input over 23,000 song transcripts written in an age-old music notation form in order to ‘teach’ the bot how to play the music.

In fact, Dr. Ben-Tal’s team isn’t the first to utilize ABC music notations to teach computers how to write music. So, even if you could make the argument that the practice for making the music itself is copyright protected, would his team be able to hold copyright protection in that process? It seems unlikely.

Does the copyright have to belong to somebody? If we’re looking to the copyright law outlined above, the answer is no. So, if Dr. Ben-Tal and his team want to exert any type of copyright protection over Bot Dylan’s songs, they’ll have to prove that their input into the songs’ creation was sufficiently creative enough to warrant that type of copyright protection – and if they can’t, these new songs officially belong in the public domain.

Should an AI machine hold copyright protection over a work? Let us know in the comments!

About the author

Nicole Martinez

Nicole is a writer and law school graduate with a dedicated focus and passion for the arts, and a particular interest in Latin American art and history. Nicole has extensive experience working with art galleries and museums in Buenos Aires and Miami, and explores cultural landscapes across the Americas through her writing.

You can e-mail Nicole at [email protected]

Add Comment

Click here to post a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

{{Privy:Embed campaign=133844}}

The Latest From Artrepreneur

  • Why Storytelling is Crucial for Artists

    Artists who identify and satisfy our ongoing search for meaning by describing art they create have already discovered this crucial truth: artists that engage in storytelling create a compelling reason for collectors and admirers to invest in their […]

  • Is Virtual Reality the Future of Art?

    As virtual reality takes hold of the film industry, artists, galleries, and cultural institutions are incorporating VR art as a component of their program or practice. We take a look at this growing trend in the art world. The post Is Virtual […]

  • Craft An Art Director Portfolio That Gets You Booked

    A well-curated art director portfolio is what potential clients and hiring managers are really paying attention to when looking for new talent. Creative Circle recruiter Gabriela Williams offers her insight for putting your best work forward. The […]

  • Four Artist Open Calls to Apply to This Summer

    Artists seeking to get their work in front of gallerists and collectors might consider applying to an open call this summer. From London to Miami, find out what curators are looking for in these four artist open calls and get your work in front of a […]

  • Four Communication Skills Every Art Student Should Master

    As an art student, you are quickly learning that effectively communicating your artistic vision is key to your success. Here, we review the four communication skills every artist should master, from interpersonal and writing skills to becoming a […]

  • How [and Where] Can I License Artwork?

    Licensing art is a common practice among artists seeking additional revenue streams. Here, we discuss the details of a typical artist licensing agreement and offer suggestions for companies you may want to approach with your work. The post How [and […]

  • Aerial Photographer Antoine Rose on Self-Funding, Selling Work

    Producing work is arduous, expensive and often challenging for Antoine Rose, a fine art aerial photographer that's shot aerial images of some of the world's most bustling landscapes. Here, he goes into detail about how he finances each project, and […]

  • How to Develop a Buzzworthy Artist Branding Strategy

    Apart from talent, artists require a certain level of “buzz” in order to progress to new levels of recognition in their art careers. Creating an artist branding strategy can elevate your work to a wider audience, and generate new interest and […]

  • Five Emerging Asian Artists to Watch

    In recent years, contemporary Asian artists are finding greater recognition in the eyes of the Western art market. We review the emerging Asian artists to watch, including Phi Phi Oanh, Donna Ong, and more. The post Five Emerging Asian Artists to […]

  • This Service Connects the Emerging Photographer With New Clients

    If you're an emerging photographer looking for steady work, Wonderful Machine can help you get your work in front of thousands of potential clients. Find out how this monthly subscription service can help you streamline your art business. The post […]

  • An Animation Artist’s Journey from College to Career

    Animation artist Mack O'Conor used his time at art school to hone his technical skills and develop his professional goals. Here, he shares his advice for navigating the college experience, from developing a solid portfolio to choosing the right art […]

  • Searching for Studio Spaces? Heed These Five Tips

    From location and ventilation to the community working within, artists searching for studio spaces should consider a variety of factors before signing on the dotted line. Independent artists and studio managers share their best strategies for […]

  • How Can I Fund Art Exhibitions and Other Projects? [Part I]

    We review the necessary steps artists seeking to fund art projects must take before they solicit financing partners, and review three key methods frequently used to fund art projects – self-funding, crowdsourcing, and fiscal sponsorship. The post […]

  • Award-Winning Makeup Artist Julie Teel’s Rise From Fashion School to Film Set

    Entirely self-taught, makeup artist Julie Teel went from studying fashion design to working as a key makeup artist on shows like 30 Rock and Gossip Girl. Here, she shares her advice for navigating the industry, from landing word-of-mouth referrals […]

  • Creative Placemaking: Art as a Genesis for Civic Transformation

    Metropolitan growth across the United States is often fueled by access to arts and culture. Artists play a pivotal role in this phenomenon, known as creative placemaking. Here, we discuss creative placemaking as a way to engage residents locally […]

  • How to Earn Your Living as a Travel Photographer

    The prospect of traveling the world while getting paid to work may seem farfetched, but these two photographers have the ticket to landing freelance creative work across the globe. Here, Andy Donohoe and Michaela Trimble share their advice for […]

  • A Recruiter’s Advice for your Video or Motion Design Reel

    Creative Circle recruiter Brooks Rowlett sifts through hundreds of motion design reels and video editor portfolios each week. Here, he shares his best advice for motion designers and video editors looking to land their next big gig. The post A […]

  • From Tattoo Artist to Brand Empire: The Rise of the Ink Mogul

    The savvy tattoo artist uses brand recognition to launch a multimedia business. These four artists have leveraged their underground celebrity status to build a brand empire, complete with product lines, book deals, and TV contracts. The post From […]

  • Exploring the Intersection of Art and Technology

    The advent of technology is re-shaping the practice of art. These educational institutions, artists, and startups are exploring art and technology's convergence in today's increasingly digital world. The post Exploring the Intersection of Art and […]

  • Work with an Artist Mentor to Get Your Career on Track

    Many of the world's most recognized artists sought inspiration and guidance from their peers. Gain insight into your practice and learn about the business of art by finding an artist mentor whose career aligns with your own vision for success. The […]

  • Why Artists Need to Make Copyright Registration a Priority

    Sharing, posting, and distributing your work online is easier than ever - but often times, visual artists find themselves dealing with online piracy issues as a result of that practice. Initiating a copyright registration routine can curb the […]

  • How Artists on Social Media Can Grow Their Following

    By sticking to the tenets of the social media pyramid, artists on social media can develop an engaged audience. The post How Artists on Social Media Can Grow Their Following appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • How [and Where] to Submit an Art Fair Application

    Submitting an art fair application doesn't have to be an arduous process. We break down which fairs are currently accepting submissions, and how you should apply. The post How [and Where] to Submit an Art Fair Application appeared first on […]

  • The Paperwork Behind Your Art Business [Part I]

    In this ongoing series, we'll review the various documents needed to get your art business up and running. First up: Crafting your artist proposal. The post The Paperwork Behind Your Art Business [Part I] appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • A Creative Career Coach Outlines a Strategy for the Working Artist

    Marc Zegans coaches artists planning the next move in their art careers. Here, he shares his proven approach for developing your practice as a working artist. The post A Creative Career Coach Outlines a Strategy for the Working Artist appeared first […]

  • Artists Who Failed – And Found Success Anyway

    Some of the world's most successful artists weren't always so revered. Meet five artists who failed to develop their art careers during their lifetime. The post Artists Who Failed – And Found Success Anyway appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • How Do Online Content Moderation Policies Treat Nudity in Art?

    As Facebook's online content moderation policies come under fire, we review creative platform Orangenius' policy on nudity in art. The post How Do Online Content Moderation Policies Treat Nudity in Art? appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • Self Employed? Five Ways To Get Into the Creative Habit

    Self-employed artists don't always leave room for inspiration. Boost productivity and get into the creative habit with these proven strategies. The post Self Employed? Five Ways To Get Into the Creative Habit appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • A Creative in a Corporate Organization: Related Group’s Art Department

    In this ongoing series, we explore the creative roles available in the most unlikely of corporations. Our first installment talks to Patricia Hanna, the Art Director of Related Group. The post A Creative in a Corporate Organization: Related […]

  • Five Alternative Income Strategies for Independent Artists

    Independent artists shouldn't have to go hungry. We explore five alternative income streams to keep your art business on track. The post Five Alternative Income Strategies for Independent Artists appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • Creative Designer Cat Lo on Executing Your Vision

    Creative designer Cat Lo works in a variety of design mediums. She shares her insight on balancing client expectations with creativity and setting freelance rates. The post Creative Designer Cat Lo on Executing Your Vision appeared first on […]

  • How One Graphic Designer Lands Gigs with the World’s Most Recognized Brands

    Graphic designer Carolina Niño shares her insight on working with brands like Adidas and Wired, while dishing on her recent collaboration with Colombian music group Bomba Estereo. The post How One Graphic Designer Lands Gigs with the World’s […]

  • Need a UX Portfolio? Recruiters Share Their Do’s and Dont’s

    A UX portfolio that well-documents your process will definitely get you noticed by creative recruitment professionals, says Creative Circle recruiter Elizabeth Calabrese-Mahnken. The post Need a UX Portfolio? Recruiters Share Their Do’s and […]

  • How One Designer Landed a Celebrity Endorsement to Launch Her Brand

    A celebrity endorsement by JBalvin has set emerging indie brand Collab Store on a path to viral success. The post How One Designer Landed a Celebrity Endorsement to Launch Her Brand appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • Need Affordable Studio Spaces in New York? chashama Can Help

    By re-purposing out-of-use properties across New York, chashama can offer artists affordable studio spaces in the city. The post Need Affordable Studio Spaces in New York? chashama Can Help appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • Why Companies Like Nike Are Shifting to Design Led Business

    While working at companies like Nike and The Gap, Lydia Hummel noticed a need for a shift toward design led business that allows creative designers to predict consumer trends. The post Why Companies Like Nike Are Shifting to Design Led Business […]

  • Five Takeaways from TEFAF’s Report on the Art Market

    The TEFAF report illustrates the challenges facing today's art market. These are the top five findings affecting artists and gallery owners. The post Five Takeaways from TEFAF’s Report on the Art Market appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • How Visual Artists Can Land Public Art Commissions

    Government leaders share their best tips for responding to a Request for Qualifications and landing public art commissions. The post How Visual Artists Can Land Public Art Commissions appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • Bill Chisholm’s Finely-Tuned Strategy for Landing Gallery Representation

    Painter Bill Chisholm has grown a successful art business by crafting a formulaic approach to gallery representation. The post Bill Chisholm’s Finely-Tuned Strategy for Landing Gallery Representation appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • Can Sharing Political Views on Social Websites Harm Art Careers?

    Artists find that sharing political art or views on social websites can sometimes have negative consequences for their art careers. The post Can Sharing Political Views on Social Websites Harm Art Careers? appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • ICYMI: The Week in Art News May 7-12

    This week in art news, Damien Hirst stirs controversy at the Venice Biennale, and an artist admits to stealing someone else's work. The post ICYMI: The Week in Art News May 7-12 appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • Why Sotheby’s Institute Art Business Degrees Fast-Track Art Careers

    Find out why Sotheby's Institute grads are uniquely positioned to excel in the art business. The post Why Sotheby’s Institute Art Business Degrees Fast-Track Art Careers appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • Frieze New York Reports Record Crowds and Million-Dollar Sales

    The sixth annual Frieze New York art fair welcomed over 200 galleries to Randall's Island Park. The post Frieze New York Reports Record Crowds and Million-Dollar Sales appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • Shokunin Gives Artisan Products a Global Sales Platform

    Richa Agarwal worked in apparel design before founding Shokunin, a global platform to artisan products and their makers. The post Shokunin Gives Artisan Products a Global Sales Platform appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • ICYMI: The Week in Art News May 1-5

    This week's art news for the art entrepreneur: The Met Gala doesn't disappoint, and New York voters have to choose their favorite design. The post ICYMI: The Week in Art News May 1-5 appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • Photographer Robert Farber on Maintaining Commercial Success

    Whether fine art, fashion or advertising photography, Robert Farber has managed to maintain decades of success as an artist. The post Photographer Robert Farber on Maintaining Commercial Success appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • Hung Yi: The Taiwanese Artist Transforming Public Art

    Hung Yi, a force in the Taiwan art landscape, is taking his penchant for public art installations to various cities across the U.S. The post Hung Yi: The Taiwanese Artist Transforming Public Art appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • Five Challenges Facing The Art Entrepreneur

    There are a variety of challenges facing today's art entrepreneur, but they don't have to sidetrack an art business. The post Five Challenges Facing The Art Entrepreneur appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • ICYMI: The Week in Art News April 24-28

    This week in art news: Sotheby's takes a hit, a muralist is caught red-handed, and Christie's makes a shift in their art business strategy. The post ICYMI: The Week in Art News April 24-28 appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • Two Russian Artists Give Their Take on the Russian Art Market

    Nastya Varlamova and Luliian Melian tell Artrepreneur that emerging Russian artists still struggle to gain international acclaim. The post Two Russian Artists Give Their Take on the Russian Art Market appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]