Copyright

Kylie Cosmetics Pilfers Artist Image in Social Media Campaign

Vlada Haggerty
Vlada Haggerty Instagram

By now, the Kardashian clan is most certainly used to being the subject of copyright infringement claims, seeing as the reality TV-made stars have their hands in just about any product empire you can think of: from cosmetics to diet pills, clothing lines and cars, the Kardashian sisters are no strangers to copyright law litigation.

Now, one of the most of-the-moment sisters is being challenged in court. Kylie Jenner’s new cosmetics line, Kylie Cosmetics, has already been the subject of several lawsuits, but the latest focuses on a supposedly intentional ripping-off of an artist’s work. According to visual artist Vlada Haggerty, a Los Angeles-based creator who also dabbles in makeup artistry, Kylie Cosmetics appropriated one of her images for its own social media campaign.

While the two images aren’t exact, they are quite close. Haggerty’s image of a pair of hands covering a model’s eyes, the fingernails painted gold with gold dripping off the subject’s fingers, perfectly encase a pair of parted red lips. Jenner’s image is almost identical: though the shades of the nails and lips vary slightly, it’s indisputable that the images create confusion regarding their original maker.

While it’s certainly true that artists are often inspired by one another, there is a line that’s been drawn to outline what constitutes copying and what doesn’t. Even so, those lines aren’t always clear – which is why its necessary to have a grip on copyright law if you intend to borrow and get inspired by other artists.

In any event, the fact that a woman who is a millionaire many times over is “borrowing” from an artist who is still trying to make it is infuriating, and Haggerty is claiming she will proceed with legal action against Jenner. In the event that she does, could she win?

Copyright, Images, and Infringement

Copyright law was designed to give certain rights to the creators of artistic works while ensuring the creative expression frees freely within the public realm. It encourages creative expression by ensuring that only creators can benefit from the sale or reproduction of their work.

Notably, copyright law protects the expression of ideas. Meaning that, an unexecuted idea that remains in your head or within a conversation between friends has no protection under copyright law. In order to be afforded copyright protection, creative works must be original works of authorship, fixed in a tangible medium, with a minimal degree of creativity. Copyright law defines a ‘creative work’ as literary works, musical works, including any accompanying words, dramatic works, including any accompanying music, pantomimes and choreographic works, pictorial, graphic and sculptural works, motion pictures and other audiovisual works, and sound recordings.

Additionally, copyright protection is assigned the moment the work is created – for example, if you write a poem on a napkin in a restaurant, that poem is automatically protected by copyright. While it’s always helpful to register your work with the Copyright Office, it’s definitely not necessary in order to be afforded the protection.

As a creator, U.S. Copyright Law affords you certain exclusive rights regarding your creative product. Only the copyright holder has the power to:

  1. reproduce (i.e., make copies of) the work;
  2. create derivative works based on the work (i.e., to alter, remix, or build upon the work);
  3. distribute copies of the work; or
  4. publicly display the work.

If we look at Haggerty’s case, then, we’re going to focus specifically on derivative works, since that’s what’s in question here.

Derivative Works: What’s Cool, and What’s Not

A derivative work is a work based on or derived from one or more already existing works. In other words, a derivative work is a work that appears to be based on someone else’s creation. The most common examples of a derivative work would be a new version of literary material – for example, a novel adapted for film or a play; a translation of a novel into another language; a sculpture based on a drawing, or a drawing based on a photograph. In order to create a derivative work, you need to have express permission from the original creator, who owns the original copyright.

Vlada HaggertyCopyright law also recognizes art reproduction as a derivative work, which is what we’re dealing with here. When you view Jenner’s and Haggerty’s images side-by-side, there’s no question that the two photographs are almost identical, save for the shades of gold and red. In order for a derivative work to satisfy copyright law’s requirement of originality on its own (and thereby be clear of potential infringement claims), the latter work must contain sufficient new expression, over and above that embodied in the earlier work. And that’s exactly where things might start to get a little tricky.

You see, whether or not a work is derivative to the extent that it violates copyright law is an extremely subjective call to make. Take, for example, an artist we’ve discussed at length here on Art Law Journal. Infamous appropriation artist Richard Prince has made a sizeable living creating works that are based on another artist’s work. In a lawsuit against by artist Patrick Cariou, a court found that his alteration of Cariou’s images – which consisted of merely drawing over Cariou’s images, was considered fair use. Let’s discuss.

Fair Use Images: Where Do You Draw the Line?

We know that copyright infringement occurs when an individual creates a derivative work from copyrighted material without express permission from the creator of the work. But there are exceptions that would shield an infringer from liability, and allow the infringer to use the work without express permission and without being liable for any damages.

The fair use doctrine is outlined by U.S. copyright laws, and the U.S. Copyright Office has even created a Fair Use Index of the overwhelming case law on the subject. Courts tend to measure fair use by these four prongs:

  • the purpose and character of the use, including whether such use is of a commercial nature or is for nonprofit educational purposes;
  • the nature of the copyrighted work;
  • the amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole; and
  • the effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work.

In the case of Richard Prince, for example, a court decided using the images was fair use because they had an artistic value to them. Prince’s expression or commentary on Cariou’s photographs built upon and shifted the Cariou’s original intention, and therefore was creative enough to be considered a fair use image.

On the other hand, it appears that Jenner’s derivative work was created solely for commercial purposes – Jenner used the image on social media, no doubt a means of advertising her cosmetics line as Jenner has millions upon millions of followers on Instagram. As such, it’s unlikely that a court would find Jenner’s work to be considered fair use.

Even so, proving that Jenner’s work was a derivative of Haggerty’s won’t be easy like we discussed here on Art Law Journal regarding the artist Cecily Brown. In order to prevail on a suit in copyright infringement, a copyright owner must show (1) access to the plaintiff’s work and (2) probative similarities between the works. If one can present this evidence and demonstrate that it’s more likely than not that the work was copied, then a claim for copyright infringement will likely prevail.

Access can be proven through evidence that the defendant had a reasonable opportunity to observe the plaintiff’s work, which in this case Haggerty can easily argue that Jenner’s team found the image on Instagram.  Plus, that evidence doesn’t need to be overly specific or concrete – Haggerty doesn’t need to show that the infringer actually viewed the work, particularly if it was widely disseminated or particularly famous. Additionally, Haggerty will have to prove that there are elements in the work sufficiently similar to warrant a court to find that the work was copied.

Even so, art is inherently subjective, and artists borrow from each other all the time. So whether or not a court will find Jenner’s work as a fair use image or copyright infringement is something we just can’t guarantee – especially because Jenner’s legal team probably has a lot more resources than Haggerty’s.

 

About the author

Nicole Martinez

Nicole is a writer and law school graduate with a dedicated focus and passion for the arts, and a particular interest in Latin American art and history. Nicole has extensive experience working with art galleries and museums in Buenos Aires and Miami, and explores cultural landscapes across the Americas through her writing.

You can e-mail Nicole at [email protected]

Add Comment

Click here to post a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The Latest From Artrepreneur

  • You Don’t Have to be an Artist to Work with Art

    Just because you don’t possess any artistic abilities – or just because you haven’t made it as an artist yet – doesn’t mean you can’t have a creative, art-filled career. There are plenty of “art […]

  • Expanding Your Art Business Beyond You

    Artists successfully running their own art business may be ready to hire an employee. We've covered everything you need to know, from tax requirements to insurance obligations. The post Expanding Your Art Business Beyond You appeared first on […]

  • What Photographers Need to Know About Shooting People [with Cameras]

    In this article, we'll review a key example of publicity and privacy issues, and what you need to know to keep your photography in the clear. The post What Photographers Need to Know About Shooting People [with Cameras] appeared first on […]

  • Getting What You Want: Basic Negotiation Tips For Creatives

    Selling and negotiating can be very intimidating. Fear not! Here are some common sense tips to negotiation that can help you get what you want. The post Getting What You Want: Basic Negotiation Tips For Creatives appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • How to Sell Art [Without Being Annoying]

    Most artists will tell you that the hardest part of their job is trying to sell their artwork to the masses. Sure, they love the creativity and the freedom being an artist provides, but how can they make a living unless they sell their work? While […]

  • Museums Deck the Halls with Holiday Cheer for All

    Check out seasonal exhibits from some of the country’s top art museums. The post Museums Deck the Halls with Holiday Cheer for All appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • Why Galleries Should Get Down with Art Fairs [A Useful Guide]

    As we're winding down from celebrating Art Basel Miami Beach, we're thinking about all the different ways galleries and artists can benefit from participating in these international art fairs. The post Why Galleries Should Get Down with Art Fairs [A […]

  • Your All Access Pass to Art Basel

    Dying to tackle Art Basel Miami Beach, but not sure where to start? You won't want to miss these stunning displays of the best of contemporary art. The post Your All Access Pass to Art Basel appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • Get Your Networking on at Miami Art Week

    Miami Art Week is the perfect time for artists to network and gather contacts to keep building an art business. Check out five events primed to bring new opportunities. The post Get Your Networking on at Miami Art Week appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • The Garment District: From Buttons and Bows to a Home for Art

    The Garment District Alliance has worked hard to evolve the area from a faded industrial center to a revitalized business district committed to bringing art to the streets. The post The Garment District: From Buttons and Bows to a Home for Art […]

  • United States of the Art: Six Destinations for the Great American Road Trip

    A cross-country road trip provides plenty of opportunities to create art. The post United States of the Art: Six Destinations for the Great American Road Trip appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • How Does a Photography Business Make Money?

    Photographers are uniquely positioned within the art world to earn money through various revenue streams. Here's how you find work. The post How Does a Photography Business Make Money? appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • The Basics of Insurance Part II: Health Insurance for Artists

    In this article, we’ll a type of insurance that you’ll want to think about as you build your art business – health insurance for artists. The post The Basics of Insurance Part II: Health Insurance for Artists appeared first on […]

  • The Emergence of the Creative Entrepreneur

    The term “starving artist” has long been part of our lexicon, signifying the significant struggle artists face bringing their creative work to market. For the lucky few that survive until they have paid their dues, the career can be […]

  • Seth Godin and Marketing for the Art World

    A good marketing strategy can help grow a business if done well. Let Seth Godin show you how to be a modern marketer in his skillshare video series. The post Seth Godin and Marketing for the Art World appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • These Five Companies Put the Art in Startup

    Technology and art are intersecting in more ways than ever, and today’s art startups are revolutionizing the way art is consumed and collected. Entrepreneurs have been intersecting art and technology since the start of the .com boom. Portfolio […]

  • The Art Museum In The Digital Age

    I talked with Steve Konick, Director of Public Relations and Marketing for the Currier Museum of Art, in Manchester, New Hampshire, to understand why art museums are still relevant The post The Art Museum In The Digital Age appeared first on […]

  • Should I Open a Corporation for My Art Business?

    About 375,000 visual artists claim to be self-employed yet many don't realize that their personal assets can be at risk. Find out how opening a corporation can help protect you. The post Should I Open a Corporation for My Art Business? appeared […]

  • Model Citizens and Protected Images: Work-for-Hire and Right of Publicity

    Last week, we discussed model releases, and an example concerning a model whose image was being used by a company in a more liberal manner than what had originally been agreed upon by the model and the company. You may recall that in this instance, […]

  • Does Copyright and Trademark Law Protect 3D Printing?

    3D printing is a relatively new art form is sweeping the internet and worrying designers and Hollywood executives alike. Along with the advent of 3D printing, a steady stream of piracy and copyright infringement cases have been reported by industry […]

  • Consider this tip before signing an International Art Contract

    Most art galleries participate in art fairs throughout the year. Many of those fairs are international, such as Art Basel Switzerland or the Hong International Art Fair. International art fairs are an excellent way to position your gallery in […]

  • Six Steps to Safer Image Sharing

    Despite the unfortunate reality that image sharing on the Internet can lead to misappropriation of your work, there are some steps that can minimize the risks. The post Six Steps to Safer Image Sharing appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • Does Freedom of Speech Protect Taking Photos of People Through Windows?

    Fine art Photographer Arne Svenson spent a year secretly taking photos of the Fosters, a family living across the street from his home. Does the Foster's Right to Privacy outweigh Svenson's Freedom of Expression? The post Does Freedom of Speech […]

  • Four Reasons Artists Should Hire Lawyers

    Think artists can't afford to hire lawyers? Actually, artists can't afford to not have one by their side. Here's four reasons why. The post Four Reasons Artists Should Hire Lawyers appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • Death and Taxes: Save Millions Through Careful Estate Planning

    Artists and collectors can minimize estate taxes on artworks by employing a planning strategy and understanding the complexities involved with assessing the work's fair market value. The post Death and Taxes: Save Millions Through Careful Estate […]

  • Can You Spot a Fake? The Trouble with Authenticating Art

    What are the challenges for collectors in authenticating artworks? What are the legal remedies when a purchased artwork is discovered to be a forgery? The post Can You Spot a Fake? The Trouble with Authenticating Art appeared first on Artrepreneur. […]

  • Planning for the Copyright Registration Process

    It has become a common refrain among lawyers who represent photographers and other artists that it is important to register your work with the U.S. Copyright Office. Although registration is not required for copyright protection, it is a […]

  • The Basics of Insurance for Artists

    There are many legal aspects of running an art-related business that could be fairly characterized as less than interesting, but few topics inspire more blank stares, or glazed-over eyes, faster than insurance. Like a lot of legal topics, thinking […]

  • Do You Know How to Protect Your Creative Business From a Devastating Lawsuit?

    Running a successful creative venture often involves understanding business just as keenly as you learn your craft, and for artists and gallery owners facing the threat of a lawsuit, it’s important to understand the steps you can take to […]

  • Videographers Must Obtain Music Licensing Rights

    Obtaining music licensing rights for videos is difficult but those that don't receive them are putting themselves and their customers at risk of a copyright infringement lawsuit. The post Videographers Must Obtain Music Licensing Rights appeared […]

  • Art Dealers Should Make Full Disclosures When Selling Artist Multiples

    New York’s Art and Cultural Affairs Law offers some pretty extensive protections to purchasers of artist multiples, defined as any fine print, photograph, sculpture cast, collage, or similar art object produced in more than one copy. […]